Everyday Low Prices

We offer our very best prices upfront to Trade & DIY alike

Secure Payments

Payments Secured by Stripe

Nationwide Delivery

Fast Nationwide Delivery Available

Excellent Customer Service

See our 1400+ reviews on Trustpilot.

Secure Payments

Payments Secured by Stripe

Nationwide Delivery

Quality Products To Your Door

Rated Excellent

See our 1400+ reviews on Trustpilot

Lightweight Metal Roof Tiles vs Plastic Roof Tiles: Which Is Better

Choosing between lightweight metal roof tiles and plastic roof tiles is a common decision for UK homeowners, builders and installers. Both options offer advantages over traditional roofing materials, but they perform differently depending on the project.

This guide compares metal and plastic roof tiles across key factors including durability, cost, noise, installation and appearance to help you decide which is best for your roof.

Metal vs Plastic Roof Tiles at a Glance

  • Metal roof tiles are stronger and more secure
  • Plastic roof tiles are quieter and easier to handle
  • Both are lightweight alternatives to traditional materials
  • Each suits different types of projects

Understanding how they differ will help you make the right choice.

What Are Lightweight Metal Roof Tiles

Lightweight metal roof tiles are typically made from steel with protective coatings. They are designed to replicate the appearance of traditional tiles or shingles while offering high strength and durability.

They are commonly used for:

  • Residential roofs
  • Garages and outbuildings
  • Secure buildings
  • Areas exposed to harsh weather

What Are Plastic Roof Tiles

Plastic roof tiles are made from recycled polymers or composite materials. They are designed to replicate slate or tile while reducing weight and improving ease of installation.

They are commonly used for:

  • Homes and extensions
  • Conservatory roof upgrades
  • Garden buildings
  • Low pitch roofing projects

Durability and Lifespan

Metal Roof Tiles

  • Extremely durable and impact resistant
  • Resistant to cracking and weather damage
  • Lifespan can exceed 30 years

Plastic Roof Tiles

  • Durable and weather resistant
  • Resistant to frost and UV damage
  • Typical lifespan of 20 to 30 years

Metal roof tiles generally offer slightly higher strength, particularly in high impact environments.

Weight and Structural Load

Both materials are significantly lighter than traditional options, but plastic tiles are usually lighter.

Metal Roof Tiles

  • Lightweight compared to concrete and slate
  • Suitable for most structures

Plastic Roof Tiles

  • Very lightweight
  • Ideal for structures with limited load capacity

Plastic tiles are often preferred for conservatories and garden buildings where weight is a key concern.

Noise Levels

Noise is one of the biggest differences between the two materials.

Metal Roof Tiles

  • Can be noisy during heavy rain or hail
  • Sound can be reduced with insulation

Plastic Roof Tiles

  • Naturally quieter
  • Better suited for living spaces

For garden rooms, offices or extensions, plastic tiles are often the better choice due to reduced noise.

Installation and Ease of Use

Metal Roof Tiles

  • Larger sheets or panels can speed up installation
  • Requires careful handling to avoid damage to coatings

Plastic Roof Tiles

  • Easy to cut and handle
  • Simple fixing systems
  • Suitable for DIY installation in some cases

Plastic tiles are generally easier to work with, especially for smaller projects.

Appearance and Finish

Metal Roof Tiles

  • Available in various profiles and finishes
  • Can replicate traditional tiles or shingles
  • Slightly more uniform appearance

Plastic Roof Tiles

  • Designed to closely mimic natural slate
  • More textured and traditional look

Plastic tiles are often preferred where appearance is a priority, especially on residential properties.

Cost Comparison

Metal Roof Tiles

  • Typically higher upfront cost
  • Long lifespan provides good value

Plastic Roof Tiles

  • Mid range cost
  • Good balance between price and performance

Costs vary depending on brand and system, but both options offer better long term value than basic roofing materials like felt.

Roof Pitch Compatibility

Metal Roof Tiles

  • Suitable for a wide range of pitches
  • Often used on both low and steep roofs

Plastic Roof Tiles

  • Suitable for low to medium pitch roofs
  • Some systems designed for pitches as low as 12.5 degrees

Both materials offer flexibility, but always check system requirements.

Security and Strength

Metal Roof Tiles

  • High resistance to impact and damage
  • Often used on secure or anti vandal buildings

Plastic Roof Tiles

  • Strong but less impact resistant than metal
  • Suitable for most residential applications

Metal roofing is often preferred where security is a concern.

Maintenance Requirements

Metal Roof Tiles

  • Low maintenance
  • Occasional inspection for coating wear

Plastic Roof Tiles

  • Very low maintenance
  • Resistant to moss and algae

Both materials require minimal upkeep compared to traditional roofing.

Environmental Considerations

Metal Roof Tiles

  • Often recyclable
  • Long lifespan reduces waste

Plastic Roof Tiles

  • Often made from recycled materials
  • Lower transport impact due to weight

Both options offer environmental benefits depending on the product.

Best Use Cases for Each Material

When to Choose Metal Roof Tiles

  • High durability is required
  • Security is a priority
  • The building is exposed to harsh conditions
  • Industrial or modern appearance is preferred

When to Choose Plastic Roof Tiles

  • Noise reduction is important
  • Weight is a concern
  • A traditional slate appearance is desired
  • The project is a conservatory, extension or garden building

Which Is Better for UK Homes

For most residential applications in the UK, plastic roof tiles are often the preferred option due to their balance of appearance, performance and ease of installation.

Metal roof tiles are better suited to:

  • Garages
  • Workshops
  • Agricultural buildings
  • High security structures

The best choice depends on your specific project requirements.

Summary

Both lightweight metal roof tiles and plastic roof tiles offer strong alternatives to traditional roofing materials.

  • Metal roof tiles provide maximum strength and durability
  • Plastic roof tiles offer quieter performance and a more traditional appearance
  • Both are lightweight, low maintenance and suitable for a wide range of applications

Choosing the right material depends on factors such as noise, weight, appearance and intended use.

At Roofin Online, we sell metal roof tiles from Metrotile and Britmet, as well as plastic roof tiles from Supaslate, Tapco Slate, Lite Slate and E Slate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are metal roof tiles better than plastic?

Metal tiles are stronger, but plastic tiles are quieter and often better for residential use.

Are metal roofs noisy in the UK?

They can be noisy during heavy rain, but insulation can reduce sound.

Which roof tiles last longer?

Metal tiles can last slightly longer, but both options offer long lifespans.

Can plastic roof tiles replace metal roofing?

Yes, in many cases plastic tiles are a suitable alternative depending on the application.

Which is cheaper metal or plastic roof tiles?

Plastic tiles are often slightly cheaper upfront, but prices vary by system.

Share the Post: